Showing posts with label Week 4. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Week 4. Show all posts

Monday, September 19, 2016

Feedback Focus

It was very fun trying out all of the different feedback techniques because I haven't really tried out anything like that before.  All of the techniques were very interesting and got me to re-evaluate how I approach giving feedback.  That being said, there were some things I didn't like about some of them.  My least favorite one was probably using the 10 minute timer.  I read much too fast for that to be helpful for me.  I finished reading the story twice and still had approximately 6 minutes left.  Then I read the comments and re-read the story for sentence structure and word choice.  I still had 2 minutes left after that that I didn't really know what to do with.  It was nice having such a large amount of time to really focus on the story itself but by then I wanted to get more into thinking about comments and just evaluating it and providing feedback rather than having to continue reading it.  I think that technique would be better for longer or more complicated writings.
My favorite technique was probably the copy-paste one, not least because I used Written?Kitten haha.  Overall, I did really like using this one so I could see my thought process throughout the entire story rather than just at the end.  However, many of my comments became more about trying to predict what would happen next or informal remarks about the characters' actions, although that might have been because I picked a particularly humorous fairy tale.
The reading out loud technique really helped me pay more attention to the rhythm and cadence of the story, something I do not try to focus on a lot when I write.  I think it would be fun for short stories like the fairy tales but not a good feedback strategy for longer works because I do not really want to spend half an hour reading a story out loud.
It was very fun trying out these different feedback techniques!  I might have to start incorporating the copy-paste technique in future feedback giving.
Dog and cat as enemies.  Web Source.

Thursday, September 15, 2016

Story: Life after Life

There’s blood in my hair again.
I run the wet, sticky strands through my fingers and flick the droplets on the ground.
And they come at me again, swords raised and howling.
Eyes closed, I swing my sword and it finds its mark, and I can hear the bounce of its head, feel the cool breeze of my sword, and taste the blood on my lips.
This is why my mothers created me, so that I could slice and chop and hack, but most of all kill and kill and kill.
It’s all I know.
I open my eyes and look around at the ruined tangle of bodies, and—
There’s blood in my hair again.

I don’t remember when he appears.  One moment I’m alone like I always am, and then suddenly he’s by my side, his slashes perfectly in time with mine.
One glance and I know he’s a god.
“You fight well,” he says when it’s all over and I say nothing because I know it’s true.
His sword flashes up and I turn it aside on instinct but slow, almost too slow, and he smiles.
“How about a practice duel?” he asks, and in answer I swing my sword at his neck.
He laughs as he jumps back, and the fight is on.
It’s hours before we stop, both too exhausted to even hold our swords up anymore.
“Rematch tomorrow?” he pants.
“Rematch,” I reply hoarsely and I watch him leave.

We duel like this every day and I start to memorize him, his attack patterns, the stubble on his cheeks, the quick spin of his blade, the flecks in his eyes, until I think I could close my eyes for an eternity and still have his image in my mind.
I’ve never met someone like him before, someone who doesn’t care that I wield swords instead of paintbrushes, someone who cracks jokes while blood spews, someone who can make me smile.
I never laughed before I met him.
I start to count the hours, minutes before he arrives.
I dream of him at night and when he comes back, I feel electrified.

One day, he’s different when he visits.  He’s with another man, who looks like him.  Both are distraught, and I feel something icy on my spine.
“Have you seen her?” the other one asks and inwardly, I know, I know.
“Seen who?”
“My wife,” he says, and I can feel something hard inside me shatter into a million tiny drops.
“No, I haven’t.  I don’t see anyone around here.”  Except for you.
He lets out a long breath.  “I see.  She was kidnapped from me, and I’m trying to find her.  I won’t be back for a while.  I’ll see you then though.”
“Y-You’ll be back?”
“Of course.”  He stopped and grabbed my hand.  “Maybe we can talk then.”
When he leaves, I can still feel the imprint of his palm in my skin.

And so I wait and wait and wait.  They don’t come to fight me anymore.  My mothers don’t need me anymore.
So I sit by the place where we dueled, and wait.
Days turn to weeks turn to months turn to years.
But I don’t mind.

I would wait a thousand lifetimes to see his face again.
Waiting.  Web Source.

Bibliography:  "Vaishno Devi:  Goddess of the Hills" by Aruna Balakrishna Singh and Durgesh Velhal.  Reading Guide.

Author's Note:  This story is based on the legend of Vaishno Devi or Vaishnavari, a goddess who was created by Lakshmi, Parvati, and Saraswati, the consorts of Vishnu, Shiva, and Brahma respectively.  She was created to deal with rakshasas terrorizing the land, and eventually was reborn into a girl who fell in love with Vishnu.  He agreed to come back and take her as his wife but she did not recognize him when he came to her in the form of an old man, so he said he would come later when she was ready.  To prove herself, she traveled deep into the mountains and meditated, but another man came by and fell in love with her.  As she had promised herself to Vishnu, she refused the other man, but his desire was too much and she eventually killed him.  She then turned herself into stone to wait for Vishnu to come back for her.  I tried to keep the big similarities, so she references her "mothers" and fights demons in the beginning, but I took out the reincarnation part.  I tried to emphasize her crazy passion for him because she seemed incredibly devoted in the story.

Monday, September 12, 2016

Extra Credit Reading Notes: Sita Part 2


  • The depiction of Shurpanakha was fantastic.  I loved how when she turned into an angry demon, you could still see the shadow of the beautiful woman she was at the bottom.
  • I really loved how the author showed what happened while Sita was held captive and what Rama and Lakshmana were up to through Haruman's song.  What an ingenious way to show both perspectives!
  • Jatayu's death was even worse in this version since he'd been with them during most of their captivity.  He was so loyal even to the end.
  • I really loved how even Sita's rakshasi guards started turning against Ravana in the end.  It really captured how people were starting to second guess starting a war for a single woman.
  • I still wish we could have seen what happened to Shurpanakha in the end.  She just vanishes from the story.  Obviously she never got Rama so what did she do?  Did she just give up and never get revenge?
  • This version where Rama holds himself back because of the law and Sita chooses to go through the purity test because she doesn't want to live with a mistrustful husband was much better in my opinion.  You could clearly see the anguish on Rama's face and it did seem as if he was very regretful.  It made more sense that he was sure she would prove her purity.
  • I also really liked this depiction of why Sita went into exile.  Having her do it by her own decision is much more satisfying than having Rama reluctantly do it.  I love how she decided her own fate and tried to find out herself what the problem was.
  • Her sons too were adorable and very well drawn.  I liked how eager they were to prove themselves and how excited they were to find out that their father was someone they had idolized.
  • Sita's decision to retreat into the earth also made much more sense this way.  I loved seeing her thoughts about how forgetful people were and how this was the only way she could finally silence all the critics.  I just wish they had been able to be together.  The little epilogue at the end was nice though to see that everything turns out all right.
  • One thing I didn't like though was the speech bubble placement.  Sometimes it got a little difficult to figure out which ones came first but maybe I'm just not used to reading comic books.
Sita asks Rama to catch the golden deer.  Web Source.
Bibliography:  Sita:  Daughter of the Earth by Saraswati Nagpal.  Reading Guide.

Extra Credit Reading Notes: Sita


  • She called Parvati Uma at the beginning.  Is this another accepted name for her?
  • I really love this perspective of Sita so far.  I love how fierce she is!  The way she wants to do her best to rid the world of evil is so heartwarming.  I also love how she takes charge of her marriage and tries to rig it so Rama wins.
  • The story of her birth is also so interesting.  I know she's an avatar of Lakshmi but I didn't realize she was also the daughter of the earth goddess.
  • Rama is so sweet and attentive to Sita.  Reading the Ramayana, you don't really get a sense of what their day to day interactions would be like, so I really appreciate how this graphic novel shows us.
  • Also, I love young Sita's interactions with her sisters!  It reminded me of how I tease my little sister.
  • I forgot that Lakshmana also married one of Sita's sisters and that she did not go with them.  I like how it goes into more detail about how that made her feel.
  • I am also really happy how this graphic novel goes into more detail about Rama forgiving Kaikeyi.  It's kind of just glossed over in the Ramayana but I like how she repents in this version.
  • The illustrations in here are gorgeous as well!  I love seeing how the characters are represented with their beautiful clothes and Rama's characteristic blue skin.
Sita graphic novel cover.  Web Source.
Bibliography:  Sita:  Daughter of the Earth by Saraswati Nagpal.  Reading Guide.

Reading Notes: Vaishno Devi


  • I liked the girl power in this one so much!  The guys were basically completely useless and it was up to their consorts to save the day.
  • Also why do they keep granting these people boons?  You'd think they'd learn after a while when they keep turning on them.
  • The part where Vaishnavi just blasts the guy who says he's indestructible is the best.  How did that even work?
  • So she was reborn into Trikuta?
  • I don't remember this part of the Ramayana?  He met her while looking for Sita?  And why did he promise to come back for her later if he loves Sita so much?
  • Some googling revealed that Vaishnavi is the feminine form of Vishnu which makes sense why he would name her that because of her devotion to him.  I am now wondering why the three goddesses originally named their heroine Vaishnavi though?  What was the relation to Vishnu there?  Why not the feminine form of one of the other gods?
  • I feel bad for Vaishnavi.  Now she has to wait so long for Vishnu.  I am still confused why he even agreed to marry her though.  What about Sita?
  • Poor Bhairon.  Although his obsessiveness gets really creepy, I still feel kind of bad for him.
  • I really like how her story links up with the geography of the land and explains some of the formations.
  • How did she transform herself into Kali?  Is Kali one of the consorts' forms?
  • It's nice that she forgave him in the end.
  • How long will she have to wait?  When is the Kaliyuga?
  • The map at the end showing the pilgrimage route is so interesting!  Really helps put everything into perspective.
Shrine at Vaishno Devi's temple.  Web Source.
Bibliography:  Vaishno Devi by Aruna Balakrishna Singh and Durgesh Velhal.  Reading Guide.

Reading Notes: Shiva Parvati: A Story of Divine Love


  • I'm confused why Sati killed herself.  I feel like that solves exactly none of the problems between Shiva and Daksha.  Why did Daksha hate Shiva so much anyway?  Was it because he didn't think he was worthy of Sati?  Wouldn't that mean he was too proud of his daughter?
  • Is heavenly nymph a metaphor or is Menaka actually a nymph?
  • What was the boon granted to Taraka by Indra that prevented his destruction?
  • I think it's really interesting that the gods can afford to wait so long.  Indra doesn't say oh your hero will be here soon.  He says first Shiva and Parvati need to marry, produce a son, and then he will grow up to defeat Taraka.  What patience.
  • I guess love can't defeat all.  This seems to me to parallel Hades and Persephone, where in some versions, Cupid is the one that shoots an arrow at Hades and makes him fall in love with Persephone.  In the Greek version, even Hades can't resist love, but in this version, Shiva not only resists but also destroys love.  It's also interesting how both cultures give love a bow and arrow.
  • Was she not devoted enough to him before?  She was kind of already his best attendant.  But I guess she had to prove herself even more worthy.
  • I really like the line later where Shiva says am I not Kama's slave too, now.  Too cute.
  • The whole seed in the river seems so round about.  Why could they not have just given birth normally?  I mean the six heads is cool too but what if there had been more nymphs there?  Or only one?
  • Does Shiva ever realize Parvati is Sati reborn?  Does Parvati retain any of Sati's personality traits?  Are they similar in any way?
Parvati.  Web Source.
Bibliography:  Shiva Parvati:  A Story of Divine Love by Kamala Chandrakant, Ram Waeerkar, and Anant Pai.  Reading Guide.